Have The Perfect Garage For Your Home & Property!

40+ Years Of Garage Expertise

Fully Custom Options

Amish Craftsmanship

Custom Garage Builder in Ithaca For The Perfect Solution!

We provide custom garages that reflect more than function - they embody pride, precision, and purpose.

It’s a space where premium Amish craftsmanship meets convenience, where tools, vehicles, and hobbies have a place to belong.

For those who value order, quality, and hard work, a custom garage becomes a personal retreat that enhances both home and lifestyle.

Materials & Craftsmanship You Can Trust

Materials & Craftsmanship You Can Trust

Your Garage. Your Way.

Your Garage. Your Way.

Questions About Garages in Ithaca? Get Your Answers Here!

Do I need a permit to build an on-site garage in Ithaca?

Yes, you will. Typically any on-site structure will require a building permit, but you can check with your local AHJ to confirm.

How do I know what size garage I need?

The answer to this question comes down to your goals for your garage. What do you plan to store in it? Do you want room for hobbies? Would you like a workshop or space to do mechanics or woodworking?

One thing is certain - no one has ever complained by having too much space and room!

How much can I customize my garage with AmishCo?

As much as you want!

Our site built garages are more flexible than prefab garages since they are built at your location, whereby avoiding transportation restrictions. if you have a customization in mind, we’d love to hear about it, and our designers will work to make that design come true! 

What is the typical lead time for an on-site built garage in the Ithaca area?

Typical lead times are 6-8 weeks. Typical build times once we arrive to build the garage is 2-5 days.

We recommend placing your order with us once you have an agreement in place with the concrete contractor. This way you can do your concrete during the lead time, and if we need to wait on you, that’s no problem! 

Do you offer prefab garages or ready-to-ship garages too?

Yes, we do! Please see our Garages page for all our prefab garage options.

Custom Garage Builder & Construction Ithaca , NY

Custom Garage Builder & Construction Ithaca , NY

Learn more about Ithaca…

Parking on a steep driveway while your lawn gear, bikes, and kayaks fight for space in a rickety old shed? In Ithaca’s lake-effect snow and gorge-carved winds, an under-sized or aging garage can turn simple chores into daily aggravation. Our on-site garage builder service removes that stress. We handle permits with the City of Ithaca, pour a code-compliant foundation that copes with hillside grades, and frame a custom garage—right in your yard—so your car stays dry, your gear stays organized, and you stay warm and worry-free. Clear timelines, one point of contact, and local craftsmanship mean you get extra space without the extra headaches.

A Brief History of Ithaca, NY

Long before Ezra Cornell envisioned a university on East Hill, the Cayuga people called this lakeshore home. European-American settlers arrived in the late 1780s, attracted by timber, water-power, and Cayuga Lake’s trade route. The village—incorporated in 1821 and renamed for the Greek island—grew into a transport hub when the Ithaca & Owego Railroad linked local mills to the Erie Canal in 1834. By the late-1800s, industries such as the Ithaca Gun Company and Morse Chain thrived, while silent-film studios at Stewart Park briefly made Ithaca a Hollywood rival. Incorporation as a city came in 1888. The founding of Cornell University (1865) and Ithaca College (1892) reshaped the economy toward education, research, and progressive politics. Today Ithaca is celebrated for waterfalls, craft food, and a lively arts scene—details you can explore on the official city website and on Wikipedia.

Top 10 Attractions in Ithaca, NY

  1. Buttermilk Falls State Park — swim beneath a frothy 165-foot cascade and hike gorge-rim trails

  2. Robert H. Treman State Park — nine miles of rugged paths lead to 115-foot Lucifer Falls

  3. Cornell Botanic Gardens — 4,300 acres of themed gardens, arboretum, and wild gorges on campus

  4. Downtown Ithaca Commons — a four-block pedestrian mall packed with indie shops and festivals

  5. Cascadilla Gorge Trail — stone staircases climb past six waterfalls between campus and downtown

  6. Museum of the Earth — hands-on exhibits span 4 billion years of natural history

  7. Sciencenter — 250+ interactive exhibits for curious kids (and grown-ups) sciencenter.org

  8. Ithaca Farmers Market — 100-stall waterfront market at Steamboat Landing, April–December

  9. Taughannock Falls State Park — view a 215-foot free-falling waterfall, taller than Niagara

  10. Herbert F. Johnson Museum of Art — I.M. Pei-designed museum with 40,000 works and sweeping lake views

We build on-site garages for all Ithaca ZIP codes and neighborhoods, including 14850, 14851, 14852, 14853, Belle Sherman, Cayuga Heights, Collegetown, Downtown Ithaca, East Hill, Fall Creek, Lansing, Northeast, South Hill, The Commons, West Hill, and more.

Each of these neighborhoods and suburbs offers its own distinct character and amenities, contributing to the diverse tapestry that makes up the city of Ithaca.