Have The Perfect Garage For Your Home & Property!

40+ Years Of Garage Expertise

Fully Custom Options

Amish Craftsmanship

Custom Garage Builder in Penn Yan For The Perfect Solution!

We provide custom garages that reflect more than function - they embody pride, precision, and purpose.

It’s a space where premium Amish craftsmanship meets convenience, where tools, vehicles, and hobbies have a place to belong.

For those who value order, quality, and hard work, a custom garage becomes a personal retreat that enhances both home and lifestyle.

Materials & Craftsmanship You Can Trust

Materials & Craftsmanship You Can Trust

Your Garage. Your Way.

Your Garage. Your Way.

Questions About Garages in Penn Yan? Get Your Answers Here!

Do I need a permit to build an on-site garage in Penn Yan?

Yes, you will. Typically any on-site structure will require a building permit, but you can check with your local AHJ to confirm.

How do I know what size garage I need?

The answer to this question comes down to your goals for your garage. What do you plan to store in it? Do you want room for hobbies? Would you like a workshop or space to do mechanics or woodworking?

One thing is certain - no one has ever complained by having too much space and room!

How much can I customize my garage with AmishCo?

As much as you want!

Our site built garages are more flexible than prefab garages since they are built at your location, whereby avoiding transportation restrictions. if you have a customization in mind, we’d love to hear about it, and our designers will work to make that design come true! 

What is the typical lead time for an on-site built garage in the Penn Yan area?

Typical lead times are 6-8 weeks. Typical build times once we arrive to build the garage is 2-5 days.

We recommend placing your order with us once you have an agreement in place with the concrete contractor. This way you can do your concrete during the lead time, and if we need to wait on you, that’s no problem! 

Do you offer prefab garages or ready-to-ship garages too?

Yes, we do! Please see our Garages page for all our prefab garage options.

Custom Garage Builder & Construction Penn Yan , NY

Custom Garage Builder & Construction Penn Yan , NY

Learn more about Penn Yan…

When you need a garage in Penn Yan, you don’t want headaches—just solid workmanship, a clean jobsite, and a structure that stands up to lake-effect weather. That’s exactly what our on-site garage builds deliver. We handle site prep, foundations, framing, roofing, doors, and finishes with a tight schedule that respects your daily routine. Permitting and inspections? We coordinate with local officials so everything moves smoothly. Designs fit village lots and lakefront parcels alike, with attention to drainage, snow loads, setbacks, and driveway tie-ins. You’ll get a durable garage that matches your home’s style, protects your vehicles and equipment, and adds resale value. No prefab surprises. Just a purpose-built garage, done right where you need it—on your property.

Penn Yan’s story starts at the north end of Keuka Lake, where the outlet powered early mills and a canal that linked to Seneca Lake. The village name blends “Penn” and “Yan,” a nod to Pennsylvania settlers and New England “Yankees.” Incorporated in 1833 and designated the Yates County seat in 1823, Penn Yan grew as a trading hub and milling center—most famously home to The Birkett Mills (founded in 1797), long associated with buckwheat and a record-setting pancake griddle used in 1987. Later, the Crooked Lake Canal era gave way to rail, and today the former corridor is the Keuka Outlet Trail. The region also reflects deep agricultural traditions, including a significant Old Order Mennonite community. Explore village services and local governance on the Village of Penn Yan site, and dive into names, dates, and milestones on Wikipedia for a fuller timeline.

Top 10 Attractions in Penn Yan

  1. Keuka Lake Outlet Trail — seven miles of wooded pathway from Penn Yan to Dresden.

  2. Seneca Mills Falls — the trail’s signature waterfall and photo spot.

  3. The Windmill Farm & Craft Market — a beloved Saturday marketplace with 150+ vendors (seasonal).

  4. Yates County History Center — museums and archives preserving local history.

  5. Arts Center of Yates County — galleries, classes, and community events.

  6. Indian Pines Park — lakeside picnicking, playground, and swimming area.

  7. Red Jacket Park — family-friendly green space on the lakefront.

  8. Keuka Lake State Park — beaches, trails, and campgrounds minutes from the village.

  9. Climbing Bines Hop Farm & Brewery — fresh ales with onsite tastings near Keuka Lake.
  10. Catharine Creek Wildlife Management Area – Marsh trails and birding between the village and Montour Falls.

We provide site-built garages for all Penn Yan ZIP codes and surrounding communities, including 14527, Geneva, Canandaigua, Waterloo, Seneca Falls, Dundee, Dresden, Rushville, Naples, Hammondsport, Middlesex, and more.

Each of these communities offers its own distinct character and amenities, contributing to the diverse tapestry that makes up the town of Penn Yan.