Have The Perfect Garage For Your Home & Property!

40+ Years Of Garage Expertise

Fully Custom Options

Amish Craftsmanship

Custom Garage Builder in Penfield For The Perfect Solution!

We provide custom garages that reflect more than function - they embody pride, precision, and purpose.

It’s a space where premium Amish craftsmanship meets convenience, where tools, vehicles, and hobbies have a place to belong.

For those who value order, quality, and hard work, a custom garage becomes a personal retreat that enhances both home and lifestyle.

Materials & Craftsmanship You Can Trust

Materials & Craftsmanship You Can Trust

Your Garage. Your Way.

Your Garage. Your Way.

Questions About Garages in Penfield? Get Your Answers Here!

Do I need a permit to build an on-site garage in Penfield?

Yes, you will. Typically any on-site structure will require a building permit, but you can check with your local AHJ to confirm.

How do I know what size garage I need?

The answer to this question comes down to your goals for your garage. What do you plan to store in it? Do you want room for hobbies? Would you like a workshop or space to do mechanics or woodworking?

One thing is certain - no one has ever complained by having too much space and room!

How much can I customize my garage with AmishCo?

As much as you want!

Our site built garages are more flexible than prefab garages since they are built at your location, whereby avoiding transportation restrictions. if you have a customization in mind, we’d love to hear about it, and our designers will work to make that design come true! 

What is the typical lead time for an on-site built garage in the Penfield area?

Typical lead times are 6-8 weeks. Typical build times once we arrive to build the garage is 2-5 days.

We recommend placing your order with us once you have an agreement in place with the concrete contractor. This way you can do your concrete during the lead time, and if we need to wait on you, that’s no problem! 

Do you offer prefab garages or ready-to-ship garages too?

Yes, we do! Please see our Garages page for all our prefab garage options.

Custom Garage Builder & Construction Penfield , NY

Custom Garage Builder & Construction Penfield , NY

Learn more about Penfield…

When you’re ready to upgrade your home with a custom-built garage, our team in Penfield, NY is here to help you transform underused space into the perfect functional extension of your property. We start by listening to your needs—whether you’re looking for secure vehicle storage, a dedicated workshop, or extra organization. We handle everything from design and permitting to material selection and construction, ensuring compliance with local codes. Our garages are engineered for upstate New York’s heavy snow loads and temperature swings, and we use durable materials that stand the test of time. With clear communication at every step and a focus on craftsmanship, we make the process smooth, so you can enjoy your new space without the usual stress of a building project. This content structure follows the Town format from the Location Pages AI Context document.

Penfield’s story begins in 1795, when Revolutionary War veteran Daniel Penfield purchased land here as part of the Phelps and Gorham Purchase. By 1800, he had built sawmills and gristmills along Irondequoit Creek to harness its falls, drawing settlers to the area. The New York State Legislature officially incorporated the community as the Town of Penfield on March 30, 1810. Through the 19th century, flour and lumber from these mills were shipped via emerging canal and road networks, anchoring the local economy and giving rise to landmarks like the Daisy Flour Mill. After World War II, suburban development accelerated: by 1970 the population had soared to nearly 24,000, and today it exceeds 39,000, making Penfield a vibrant Rochester suburb. The historic “Four Corners” intersection of Five Mile Line and Penfield Roads still reflects the town’s milling heritage amid modern growth. Learn more on the official Penfield town page and Wikipedia.

Top 10 Attractions for Penfield, NY

  • Wickham Farms: A family-friendly farm with seasonal activities like apple picking, sunflowers, and hayrides.

  • Powder Mills Park: A large park with trails, skiing, fishing, and historic mill sites.

  • Ellison Park: Wooded park offering hiking, sports, disc golf, and a dog park.

  • Daisy Flour Mill: A historic flour mill turned event venue by Irondequoit Creek.

  • Stephen Phelps House: A preserved 1810s Federal-style home in Penfield.

  • Hipp–Kennedy House: An 1830s Greek Revival home with early log structure.

  • Irondequoit Creek: A scenic stream known for trout fishing and kayaking.

  • Penfield’s Four Corners Historic District: The historic heart of Penfield with 19th-century buildings.

  • Schaufelberger Park: A small village green with a clock and founder’s statue.

  • Heritage Park: A quiet community park with open space and walking paths.

We provide our custom on-site garages for all Penfield Penfield ZIP codes and surrounding communities, including 14526, 14450, 14502, 14580, 14625, East Rochester, Fairport, East Penfield, Pittsford, Penfield Center, Cobbs Hill, Hannans Corner, Twelve Corners, Bushnell Basin, West Webster, Bay View, Glen Edith, Brighton, Egypt, Roseland, and more.

Each of these communities offers its own distinct character and amenities, contributing to the diverse tapestry that makes up the town of Penfield.